If my Varsity schedule says we are going to Bobcat, and a kid is a Varsity wrestler, then he goes to Bobcat! It is what it is!
Let me revamp/clarify... If I plan on him wrestling in our league or the regional tournament, I put him in the line-up regardless. However, I have had kids in the past that were just kids for dual purposes only as I did not want to have an open weight. I guess it's really a case by case basis and you have to trust the judgement of the coach knowing the kid well enough to decide what is best for the kid and the team.