Just a hypothetical here (and thank you for the debat, there is only good that can come from sharing thoughts on this stuff), what if a wrestler was leading another by seven or eight points late in a match and fell on his back with ten seconds left and got pinned. The next year we come to the same point in the meeting. Is that match going to be the determiner that we use over all others? There are so many ways we could go with that deal. I think this specific weight brought to the table a lot of knowns. We knew both wrestlers were high quality kids. We knew we needed to split them. Course then along came sophomore Malloy and beat a state champ in the second round of the tourney lol. It is a tough deal no doubt and you make some valid points. Be sure to put your thoughts on the criteria thread Ihave posted here. I would value your comments.