Jhris, I can't agree/disagree with the Hoxie results because I have not seen them. I do agree that your 52 & 60 pounders are SOLID! I think falls are a stretch, even with Hoxie's studs. Overall, it doesn't matter, because it is rare to have two teams with all of their guns on the mat, and this is all for fun. Congrats on everyone keeping this topic lighthearted, too.
Dual state is the way to go.
By the way, what if you take Hoxie's all time greats vs. Manhattans All-Star team?