Looking at the brackets from the last four years Grater and Taplin are very close on wins and losses.

Grater - Fr. 32-7, #130, 6th place at state
So. 38-0, #140, 1st place at state
Jr. 36-0, #145, 1st palce at state
Sr. 37-0, #145, 1st palce at state
Grater had two pins at the state tournment his senior year and a 5-1 dec. and a 8-3 dec. at state. That leaves Grater's career recored at 143-7.

Taplin - Fr. 33-5, #145, 5th place at state
So. 36-1, #152, 1st place at state
Jr. 34-0, #160, 1st place at state
Sr. 41-0, #160, 1st place at state
Taplin had three pins at state and one maj.dec. 14-5. That leaves Taplin's career recored at 144-6.