i would go caldwell over ely. simply becuase caldwell has been so dominant and i think if you talk head to head match ups you have to throw out the advantage the bigger wrestler would have on weight. if you theoretically put caldwell and ely at the same weight...i think caldwell wins. in the other classes i would have to take the 130lber. except 321A...which i cant really comment on cuz i have seen niether kid wrestle.